Page 26 - sm02_2020

Criteria for Judging the ‘Best Presented artiCle’ in the
‘Business & eConomy’ segment of students magazine

Detail of Student

Name of Student
Registration No.
Campus
Contact No.
Email address:
Detail of Article submitted

Topic of Article
Total Word Count
Unique Content (%)

Review Criteria
Sr. Criteria Description Criteria Points Points Earned
Initial Review Final Review
1 Originality of Contents Creative; Own writing; Max. 80% unique con- 25
tents; References provided
2 Topic Selection Topic is short, specific and catchy; Relevant to 10
current scenario
3 Presentation Style Well presented; perfect paragraphing; suitabili- 20
ty of sub-headings; flow and connectivity of
paragraphs; charts and graphs relevant to text
4 Accuracy of Facts and Figures Authentic sources of References; Valid Reason 15
and Logic, if own derived
5 Length of Essay Minimum 300 words; Maximum 500 words 05
6 Perfection of Language Short and Precise; Clear and easy understandable; 25
Free from spelling mistakes and grammatical
errors; avoidance of superfluous vocabulary
Total 100

Review Procedure
a) Step 1: Initial Review of articles shall be made by the R&P Department.
b) Step 2: Final Review of all articles to be made by a member of R&P Committee on SPS to be decided by the Chairman.
c) Step 3: Final Score/Points Earned on each article to be compiled by R&P Department and placed in R&P Committee
Meeting for approval
d) Step 5: The name and picture of the Winning Student to be published in the next issue of Future CMAs.

This criterion has been approved by the Research and Publications Committee in its meeting held on 15th January 2020.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF NEWS/MATERIAL RECEIVED FROM STUDENTS

The R&P Department has received an encouraging response from the students who have sent news; articles; write-ups and
other materials, including poetry; art work; jokes; quotes etc. related to five regular segments. As per approved policy, all
such submissions shall be considered for publication on ‘first-come- first-serve basis’. The Editorial Board reserves the rights
to amend/alter any news or material for purposes of clarity and space as well as not to consider any material for publication
in magazine for valid reasons.
Provided below are the names of students whose submissions /additional material have been received which would be
considered for publication, subject to approval of Editorial Board, in the next issue of the magazine:
Karachi/Hyderabad: Syed Ammar Waris, Shahzad Ullah Baig
Faisalabad: Muhammad Talha Sabir, Zeeshan Ather, Muhammad Osama, Junaid Shahid, Anum Hafeez
Lahore: Zahida Saeed
Islamabad: Muhammad Asjad, Sher Ali Samo, Usman Ghani, Iqra Bibi
The above may please be treated as acknowledgement receipt of the materials received from students.

ICMA Pakistan’s Students’ e-Magazine 26 Volume 2.1 | February 2020